Just Like Starbucks Molasses Cookies

A few years ago, on an afternoon trip to Starbucks, I decided to break from my usual coffee-only habit. I ordered a Chai Latte and a molasses cookie. While I loved the latte, nothing could break my coffee loyalty. However, I fell in love with the molasses cookie. I knew I had to find a way to duplicate that recipe.

It took some trial and error, and a few complete flops, until I came up with this winning combination. These cookies are a huge favorite in our house, even with all of the kids.


Just Like Starbucks Molasses Cookies

  • 3/4 c. butter or margarine
  • 1 c. brown sugar
  • 1 egg
  • 1/3 c. blackstrap molasses (or 1/2 c. plain molasses)
  • 2 1/2 c. flour (You can use any combination white/whole wheat flour)
  • 2 t. baking soda
  • 1 t. cinnamon
  • 1/2 t. salt
  • 1/2 t. nutmeg
  • 1/2 t. ginger
  • For rolling dough – 1/2 c. white sugar

1. Cream the butter or margarine and brown sugar together until fluffy. Add the egg and molasses and beat for an additional minute.

2. In a small bowl, combine the dry ingredients. Sift or stir with a fork or whisk for 30 seconds.

3. Add the dry ingredients to the wet ingredients and mix just until combined. Cover dough and refrigerate for 1 – 2 hours, until firm.

4. Roll heaping tablespoons of dough into a ball, then roll through white sugar. Place on lightly greased cookie sheets and bake at 350 degrees for 10-15 minutes.


This process will result in light, cake-like cookies. If you prefer crispier cookies, flatten the sugar-coated balls of dough slightly with your palm or the bottom of a glass.


55 thoughts on “Just Like Starbucks Molasses Cookies

  1. these sound AWESOME. My sister works at starbucks and she loves molasses cookies. I have some blackstrap molasses left over from my last cookie attempt. I’m definitely going to give these a try.

  2. Yeaaa, I have all of these ingredients, including the blackstrap molasses (good for anemics!). I’ve never tried the cookies from Starbucks, but these look great. Thanks!

  3. Kate! I LOVE YOU!!! I mean that with all of my heart! These are my favorite cookies in the world and I will be baking up a storm soon!

  4. Mmmmmm! Thank you! 🙂 I love Starbucks Molasses cookies. Apparently you can’t get them nationwide – only in certain markets. I found this out the hard way when I have lived & travelled to other parts of the country. I can’t wait to try these!

  5. I made these Saturday night and they were delicious! My children said they were “Soooo good” and asked for several. Thank you for this recipe!

  6. I haven’t made these, but will. I was just wondering how many cookies you get out of this recipe?? I’m trying to calculate the calories and such.


  7. These cookies were AMAZING!!!!! I have never actually had the starbucks kind, but these are my new favorite cookie. I actually added in some chopped up candied ginger I had, too. Best cookies in the universe!!!!

  8. This has become a favourite with everybody in our household. Thanks for sharing. Each time I have made them they end up a little too flat. Should I add a little more flower. I don’t flatten them at all on the baking sheet. Flat or not, the flavour is great!

  9. These were delicious – dangerously so, since a little less self-control would have resulted in me single-handedly eating the whole batch. I love a soft, flavorful cookie, and these fit the bill quite nicely. Thank you for a wonderful recipe that is sure to become a family favorite!

  10. I have been going bananas trying to make the perfect cookie. I had gotten my fat, flour, sugar ratios the same as yours listed. I just stumbled upon your site and saw that I was not using cold dough, so I am going to try one more batch with cold dough. Keeping my fingers crossed this works!

  11. These cookies are so yummy, I like to make them the size that Starbucks makes them so I use an ice cream scoop to size the cookie, which then yields about 12 cookies.

  12. So excited to make these!!! May I ask how many cookies this recipe yields?
    I’d like to make them for a family event! Thanks!

  13. I made these the other day and they were the bomb! I shared your recipe on my blog with your website linked so that others may try them too…a wonderful holiday cookie : ) Thanks for coming up with such a yummy recipe. Merry Christmas!

  14. Uh-oh. I have the dough in the fridge right now. I absent-mindedly used 2 sticks of butter. Ahh! We’ll see what happens :/

  15. I made them yesterday. Very good. Don’t over bake : they ” crisp up” afterwards.
    I drizzled with white icing and sprinkled red and green sugar crystals for Christmas flair! Great recipe, thank you!

  16. I made a double batch of these recently to take to work and counted the amount it made which came out to 25, so I punched it in a recipe builder for nutritional value I would only use this as a loose guide but here’s what I came up with- calories 100/carbs 18/fat 4/protein 2/sodium 115/sugars 8. However you will want to consider Blackstrap Molasses is higher in Iron, Magnesium and Calcium than regular molasses so there’s added benefit there. A decedent treat no doubt, but worth it!

  17. They know the merchandise by the reputation of the product.

    Home Depot’s largest store is located in Anaheim,
    California. It also calls attention to the entire staff
    that the employee has been rewarded.

  18. Genuine, authentic suggestions make or even get out the
    connected – In account (similar to sources can for job prospect).
    Complete intuition does seldom disappoint you within these
    situations. Here is just how to stay away from this and/or perfectly backlink connections inside Android contacts record.

  19. They soon form an after work gathering, Durden names, Fight Club.

    Time spent to create something special is always heartwarmingthis ultimately is the reason behind
    these cards charm. Always try to remember that you will
    have more success if you don’t push too hard, particularly if you feel some resistance.

  20. A group can be defines as two or more people who come together and shares a common definition and evaluation of themselves.
    Nonverbally, you show you’re a skilled listener by
    maintaining steady eye contact. Some end users might
    consider that the method of uninstalling after which reinstalling the sport all over again is undesirable.

  21. The apple is the best source for catechins, a substance that is believed to be potent against cancer cells.
    There should be proper access, lighting, signage, seating arrangements for the disabled.

    People suffering from asthma may experience severe conditions in the presence of
    such mold.

  22. Whether people themselves have selected not to get confessed in a medical service
    or their parents want them to be handled at house, this health system is a perfect solution that can confirm
    to be affordable as well. Before such mold
    invades your entire house, you must prevent its growth. It
    affects our ability to cope with and manage change, life events and transitions such
    as bereavement or retirement.

  23. Every Android mobile application runs in its own Linux
    Process, the process is initiated when any one of the code is triggered to be executed and this is turned off when the system no longer requires the code to be executed.
    Learning how to develop an android app is
    not a simple process, but if you can bend the learning curve some more,
    then why not. Not only will you be able to stay away
    from the mother dragon for a longer period of time, you will upgrade faster and progress in ranks much quicker.

  24. The development team also decided to touch up some of the visual elements as the video
    game can now be displayed with a native resolution of 1080p.
    With the introduction for you to Play – Station network card, it became possible for one to lose all the unwanted CDs
    that occupied a whole bunch of place in the particular drawers.
    The Internet is a place where people can have lots of fun.

  25. Microsoft has announced all new Xbox 360 owners will get Gold Service
    feature for the 1st 30 days. This got me interested in what parental
    controls are available for the x – Box. An Xbox 360 repair guide which provides step-by-step directions will
    make it much more simple to solve your problems
    and leave no doubt if you are doing the right thing or

  26. The qualified teams have been divided into eight groups of four teams each, which
    will compete in two stages of this event. The fifa 13 coins are the new ways to make you
    feel the best as a team owner. If you haven’t
    been playing such games, you are missing out on all the fun.

  27. Pla – Smart Perplexus Maze Game is a challenging and a fun game in which the
    player has to move a small marble around different tracks within a transparent sphere.

    If you are a media geek or a person who plainly wants to have
    lots of fun, the Android Tablet is the right tablet PC for
    you. ‘Scurvy Scallywags’ on Android plays pretty much like it did on an Apple product.

  28. Magazines and periodicals covers interests ranging from political, business,
    trade, auto, electronics, computer, fashion, sports, travel, adult and many more.
    Candidate, specially freshers, are strongly advised to revision their Academics.
    s new rules, but there are some great sales
    and marketing ideas.

  29. The elephant was given to Diem in a much publicized ceremony.

    The other way round one can simply choose the exciting places where one can engage oneself or with the other members of the family.
    As per our observation the absence of entry barrier and various economic liberalization procedures adopted by the government has positioned Vietnam as the most
    lucrative market in Asia.

  30. If it is a family tour then visiting the artifacts and museums can benefit the
    children while the visit made for a couple can be better complemented with going to the remote places located amidst the lap of nature.
    Our research has also analyzed the Vietnam retail market by
    province and ownership providing their future scenarios and also by retail formats.
    If you were discharged after such date because of a disability acquired in line of duty
    then you are qualified.

  31. It is recommended that when women take natural herbs they
    drink plenty of water with them, and also to get maximum results lead
    the kitchen connoisseur, consisting of a good diet and physical exercise.
    These phytoestrogens are sort of like the naturally existing
    estrogens that are created by the body, but are likely to be a spot
    weaker than the proper thing. We overheard guys
    commenting “full toned square screen.

Comments are closed.